The Assessment: Phil Jones’ Dilemma
The Assessment: Phil Jones’ Dilemma
Phil Jones is a project leader at Engineering Co and leader of a team operating in six different geographical locations across two time zones. Phil is a mechanical engineer and his technical skills have been recognised by Engineering Co and he has made steady progress with the company since leaving university.
Phil has been the Senior Project Team Leader for six months on a blue chip project, an integrated rail and metro system in the Gulf region of the Middle East. The project went out to global tender and Engineering Co won the contract for supplying rails, switching gear, electrical supply and the metro stations and it secured the contract largely on its ability to deliver high quality projects on time, on budget and fit for purhref="https://lgfwz.com/zh-my/tags-nw6e-0.html" target="_blank" >pose. Engineering Co did not submit the lowest tender for the project but the client was convinced of its technical and managerial capabilities which have given it a clear competitive advantage. The company enjoys a strong industry reputation and for engineering and management graduates, it is an ‘employer of choice’ as it is widely regarded as having one of the best graduate development programmes in Britain. Engineering Co is essentially a project-based organisation but its structure is nominally a combination of functional and divisional units. There is a clear division between planning and execution in Engineering Co and while strategy is ‘owned’ by the senior management team, the majority of the work is delivered through project teams.
Phil Jones is only thirty years of age but he is seen as having senior management potential and has been given leadership of one of the key project teams. Phil is based in Surrey, close to London, and he travels frequently throughout the UK to meet project team members and he is on-site in the Gulf every six-to-eight weeks but crucially, he is the only one in the team who has met the other members face-to-face. The project is still at the planning stage of the work and it has gone reasonably well up to now but Phil believes that performing ‘reasonably well’ means it is operating sub-optimally and that is not good enough; Phil wants it to be an exceptional team and he is determined to drive it towards that objective. The project team members were all internal applicants and Phil was given the final say on who would be recruited to the team. There was a significant number of internal applicants and the selection process was exhaustive, with each member being selected across a range of competencies. Phil was certain that he had the right people with the rights skills in the right jobs at the right time but six months into the project, he senses undercurrents of tension amongst team members. In several instances team members have agreed with each other and it seems to Phil that they are doing this to avoid any overt conflict. Phil is not going out of his way to generate conflict but he believes that a certain level of it would be good for the team as it might bring some of the undercurrents into the open where they could be acknowledged and addressed and which might allow the team to develop into a more effective and efficient unit.
Phil is angry at the way it is going for he feels he is losing focus on the project as his time is increasingly being taken up with ‘people issues’, an area where he is the first to admit his strengths do not lie. Some of the issues Phil has had to deal with include team members stating that they are still not 100% sure of their role in the team and consequently work has been duplicated and that has cost the project time and money. Phil was pretty sure everything would somehow have fallen into place as at first people appeared to be committed to the project and the team. He thought he had made the immediate project goals clear and he assumed everyone knew what it was they had to as he thought he had given the team clear boundaries. Phil has also found that there are cultural issues around authority and responsibility and when it comes to decision-making, several team members look to him to make the calls. This irritates Phil as he has told people repeatedly that they are empowered to make decisions and they must stop referring every problem back up the line, but several team members countered that they are unsure of what they can make decisions on and that Phil is inconsistent, telling people to be pro-active and then overruling them later.
Phil is a problem-solver and he decided that the best course of action was to get some books on teams and groups to gain insights into what teams are, how they function and to gain a better understanding of some of the dysfunctional aspects of teams. Initially, Phil approached these issues as an engineer; the team is a system and if the problems are analysed dispassionately the analysis will generate solutions which should be accepted by everyone as they are the outcome of a rational decision-making process. Phil takes comfort in certainty and he wishes at times that people would just act rationally and accept his decisions as they are based on what is best for the project. Grudgingly, Phil has come to the view that he is a mini HR Manager first and a Project Team - Leader second and the project team is in danger of losing focus and momentum. Phil read Bruce Tuckman’s stages of group development with interest and he is now convinced that the team is stuck at the storming stage and he is unsure of what has to be done to get it to the performing stage. He is desperate for the team to succeed, not only for his own career. Phil wants all of the team members to be able to look back on their time on the project team as a positive experience and he wants people to be proud to have on their CV that they were part of the Gulf Metro Project Team.
-
病假工资发放标准2023是什么
相信很多劳动者都有这样的疑问:病假有工资吗?病假工资是怎么计算的?请长病假和短病假工资计算是不是一样的?劳动法病假工资规定是怎样的?下面万州律师将针对这些问题向大家详细介绍劳动法病假工资规定,希望对您有所帮助。一、病假工资发放标准2021一、病假工资发放标...
-
社群营销策划方案【新版多篇】
社群营销策划方案篇一重视互动社交媒体,特别是主流微博平台的运营一、微博营销的目的1.品牌营销的利器;2.客户及时互动的绝佳助手;3.危机公关的理想选择;4.市场调查与产品开发的创新工具。微博为企业提供了一个形式别样的企业品牌营销平台,为企业省下不少的硬性营销...
-
在援青干部人才代表座谈会上的讲话
在援青干部人才代表座谈会上的讲话(摘要)当前,X正处于历史上最好的发展时期。这是政治优势的呈现期,我们坚决落实总书记对X工作重要讲话指示批示精神,深化对“三个最大”省情定位和“三个更加重要”战略地位的认识,充分发挥中国特色社会主义制度优势,用好对口支援和东...
-
经验做法:激发干部想干事能干事内生动力
经验做法:激发干部想干事能干事内生动力近年来,县坚持严管与厚爱结合、激励与约束并重,统筹做好思想引导、培养使用、容错纠错等各方面工作,激发广大干部想干事、能干事的内生动力,让担当实干蔚然成风。一、干工作、抓落实,会干是前提。针对干部能力不足、经验缺乏等...
相关文章
- Unit 3 The sentence patterns of Comparative Degree 同级比较句型(微课)
- Air Quality Devices - Marketing Research Proposal
- Cultivate students' good English learning habits,Improve the effectiveness of classroom teachin
- This is my father 教学设计Lesson one
- 《Unit 5 What does he do? Part A Let’s learn》 教材分析与处理
- A comparison of Chinese and Korean dining etiquette 中韩饮食礼仪之比较
- Lesson20 The Spring Festival Is Coming!说课稿2篇
- PEP四年级上册Unit2 My schoolbag Let’s spell 教学案例
- Unit 6 How many? Part ALet’s learn & Let’s chant教学设计
- 10 Tips on Chinese Table Manners